Thanks for the memories!

Although it has its amusing moments, in eneral the plot does not convince.

Exactly the movie you think it is, but not the movie you want it to be.

If you like to be scared, if you like to laugh, and if you like to learn a thing or two at the movies, this absolutely cannot be missed.

A young man works as a projectionist at a movie theatre but dreams of becoming a famous detective. His studies toward this goal are put to the test when visiting his girlfriend. A rival steals his girlfriend's father's watch and frames him for the crime. He is forbidden from seeing her again. Now he must fight to clear his name.Buster Keaton at his finest - a classic of the Silent Era. Good plot, all of which is a central structure around which Keaton can build some incredibly clever scenes, sub-plots and sight gags. Some of these are brilliantly funny and intelligent, as Keaton toys mercilessly with the audience. The pool scene - the adventure of the exploding ball - is a great example.Some very clever cinematography and editing too - some of the visual effects and stunts were quite innovative for their time.Superb.

This movie was very delightful to watch even though it was a silent movie. The plot was well put together even though at some points one felt as if Sherlock would have no chance at the girl or proving that he were innocent. This made me pity him, but also respect this character as he was quite a determined man. In the end, Sherlock does win the girl however, who realizes that he was innocent and went back to him at the theatre. This leaves the audience with the idea in the back of their minds, that things can actually work out no matter how dim or gloomy the chances may seem.

Buster Keaton Sherlock Jr. (1924) is an entertaining, smart and humorous film. The camera work, stunts, and flow of the film seemed to be very refined and intricate for this time in film making. The flow from scene to scene was very easy to follow and made sense throughout. Some scenes shock you as you watch, and makes you wonder how in this time they so flawlessly created the advanced scene. Buster Keaton was the perfect actor for this movie. His blank stare and ability to convey emotion without speaking was incredible. The film had many points throughout where you will find yourself laughing out loud. Something many find unlikely for silent films. Overall, I would highly recommend watching this short film!

Sherlock Jr. is a creative and refreshing take on a mystery story. Many elements and subtle themes help the viewer stay invested along with any and all sight gags. The characters included such as the sly detective Sherlock Jr, keep the story progressing at a good pace. Although a bit cliché, the story is told in an interesting and inventive way that would definitely be considered a marvel of its time. Clever editing techniques and interesting set add to the ambiance that Buster Keaton must have painstakingly tried to perfect. Overall, definitely a good watch if you are interested in mystery comedies!