The movie's neither hopeful in contrived ways, nor hopeless in different contrived ways. Somehow it manages to be wonderful

The biggest problem with this movie is it’s a little better than you think it might be, which somehow makes it worse. As in, it takes itself a bit too seriously, which makes most of the movie feel kind of dull.

Great movie. Not sure what people expected but I found it highly entertaining.

This movie tries so hard to be funny, yet it falls flat every time. Just another example of recycled ideas repackaged with women in an attempt to appeal to a certain audience.

Let me begin by stating that I am a die-hard Mahira Khan fan. That said, I thought that Bin Roye, while not the best, was a good film. Mahira and Humayun were good together. The age difference between Saba and Irtiza was appropriate to me, because the difference in the ages of the two protagonists was made clear at the beginning. The love triangle between Saman, Irtiza and Saba was tastefully presented and the story-line while thin was successful because of the acting skills of the lead actors. The support cast did a fair job in keeping the story moving. My only wish is that the screen play was tighter; there were times when the subplots just seemed to die without explanation or follow-up.

BIN ROYE Director: Momina Duraid, Shahzad Kashmiri Writer: Farhat Ishtiaq Producer: Hum Films**Starring Jawaid Sheikh, Zeba Bakhtiyar, Humayun Saeed, Mahira Khan, Armeena Rana Khan a movie based on novel BIN ROYE ANSOO written by Famous Digest, TV writer Farhat Ishtiaq, screenplay is also written by the same writer. The movie generic is romantic drama; literally it's a complete and pure drama, not a single moment we cannot assume that we are watching a film. Good Script, Depth Message, Good Pasteurize. Mahira Khan acting was on the top again after Serial HUMSAFAR. There are also numbers of blunders:- 1- Humayyun Saeed is not fit for the role of Irtaza, he looks much older than Mahira and Armeena. Ali Zafar, Fawad Khan, Mikael suited the role. 2- Mahira never looks a younger sister of Armeena even she looks older than Armeena more than 7 years old. 3- Why Director, Writer force for USA location instead it was Dubai, why forced it was USA? 4- One by One Dead forcefully why? first Hummayun Saeed's parents, then Armeena… are they accidental family? 5- Film start Pre-Marriage of forcefully young Hummayun with beard still looks 45 years, Mahira looks 32 after continuity of 7-8 years both looks still old and same. 6- How Armeena Knows Mahira's Secret love? Even Hero don't know's? However a great watchable movie

Salam , just watched this movie on 19th July at Cineplex Centaurus Islamabad it was the only show , to be honest I wasn't much excited as I already read the reviews of its premiere in Karachi where public said that story was weak but still I had some hope and faith but as soon as the movie started all the expectations went in vain from very first scene the movie seemed a typical traditional Pakistani fair where sweet dish was shown being prepared with dialogs very weak indeed but yet Mahira Khan caught your attention because of sharp colors used in dressing and sets anyway the movie then started with old typical girl loves boy plot where boy doesn't show much interest then later he goes abroad where he falls in love with someone and marries blah blah , then crying tears and every thing happens so quickly in this movie that you don't even know what is happening scene to scene details are not shown every thing is done in so hurry as if one's halwa was getting cold , it seemed as if they made this story for drama but later decided to put whole drama in 2 hour movie and that too forcefully so script was extremely poor and so weak it would have worked 15 years back but no chance in today's era. Acting was quite good by all three lead members Humayun was superb as usual with mature acting , Mahira was sharp , Armeena had small screen time but did her part best rest cast was wasted to be honest it seemed extra to me. Music was the best part of the movie with all 5 songs outstanding straight from the heart , background score was superb and fantastic really enjoyed all songs especially Maula Maula which was magical on screen especially songs 2nd part at the end . So for me this movie brings nothing new in revival of cinema no path breaking element in it but only contributes a little bit in revival cycle only tiny addition not much , with this cast they could have made a brilliant love story but chance missed and main culprit was bad script going no where any way not a recommendable piece of cinema . Overall 6/10 , Script 3/10 , acting 8/10 , Music 10/10.

It was an Amazing Movie overall. Its Music won't let you blink your eyes! Acting is superb! An example for those who thinks without item numbers and vulgar scenes- a movie can't be made. Only thing that could have been improved is direction- Some of the shots were Amazing, but few of them could have bee improved. Acting was Fabulous - Mahira khan was outstanding, Hamayu Saeed has done a very good Job. Areema was looking stunning. Story was good. I don't know how close it was from the Novel - but i am looking forward to watch its drama serial. Also, I am very excited to see revival of Pakistan Film industry, and i am hoping that i won't copy any Bollywood stuff. Music- 10/10, Acting- 10/10, Direction 7/10, Story 8/10